Process Review in ELLINE Journal

Process Review in ELLINE Journal

Process review in ELLINE Journal refers to the rigorous evaluation and assessment process that each manuscript undergoes before publication. This critical stage ensures that only high-quality, relevant, and scholarly contributions are selected for inclusion in the journal.

  1. Submission: The process begins when authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's online submission system. Each submission must adhere to the journal's guidelines regarding format, structure, and scope.

  2. Editorial Screening: Upon submission, manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening. The editorial team checks for adherence to submission guidelines, basic formatting, and ethical considerations. Submissions that do not meet these criteria may be returned to authors for revision or rejected at this stage.

  3. Peer Review: Manuscripts that pass the initial screening undergo a rigorous peer-review process. ELLINE Journal follows a double-blind peer-review system where the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed to ensure impartiality and objectivity.

    • Selection of Reviewers: Qualified experts in the field of English language and literature education are selected as reviewers. They possess expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject matter and methodology.

    • Review Criteria: Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on criteria such as originality, significance to the field, methodological rigor, clarity of presentation, and adherence to ethical standards.

    • Review Reports: Reviewers provide detailed feedback and recommendations to the editorial team. Reports typically include strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript, suggestions for improvement, and a recommendation for acceptance, revision, or rejection.

  4. Decision Making: Based on the reviewers' reports, the editorial team makes a decision regarding the manuscript. This decision may include:

    • Acceptance: Manuscripts that meet the journal's standards and align with its scope are accepted for publication pending minor revisions or as is.

    • Revision: Manuscripts that show promise but require revisions to address reviewers' feedback. Authors are typically given an opportunity to revise and resubmit their work.

    • Rejection: Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's standards or are deemed not suitable for publication are rejected. Authors are provided with constructive feedback to assist in further development of their work.

  5. Final Publication Preparation: Once accepted, manuscripts undergo final formatting and copyediting processes. Authors may be required to address any remaining editorial queries or formatting issues to ensure consistency and clarity.

  6. Publication: Accepted manuscripts are published in the biannual issues of ELLINE Journal, released in April and October. Each article contributes to the scholarly dialogue and advancement of knowledge in English language and literature education.

Process review in ELLINE Journal is designed to uphold the highest standards of academic integrity and ensure that published research makes a significant contribution to the field. By maintaining a thorough and transparent review process, the journal aims to foster excellence in scholarship and support continuous improvement in English language and literature education worldwide.